| Year | Genre | Translator(s) | Title & Author | Judge(s) | Book | Language |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2022 | Prose | Anna Chiafele and Lisa Pike | Penelope by Silvana La Spina |
Nerina Cocchi - Douglas Grant Heise - Barbara Ofosu-Somuah |
 |
Italian |
| 2021 | Prose | Stephen Twilley | Diary of a Foreigner in Paris by Curzio Malaparte |
Stiliana Milkova - Minna Zallman Proctor - Will Schutt |
 |
Italian and French |
| 2020 | Prose | Frederika Randall | I Am God by Giacomo Sartori |
Jeanne Bonner - Richard Dixon - Antony Shugaar |
 |
Italian |
| 2019 | Prose | Simon Carnell & Erica Segre | The Eight Mountains by Paolo Cognetti |
Alta Price - Zakiya Hanafi - Allison Grimaldi-Donahue |
 |
Italian |
| 2018 | Prose | Elizabeth Harris | For Isabel, A Mandala by Antonio Tabucchi |
Geoffrey Brock - Peter Constantine - Sarah Stickney |
 |
Italian |
| 2017 | Prose | Matthew Holden | We Want Everything by Nanni Balestrini |
Elizabeth Harris - Jim Hicks - Olivia Sears |
 |
Italian |
| 2016 | Prose | Ann Goldstein | The Story of the Lost Child by Elena Ferrante |
Michael Moore - Jamie Richards - Russell Valentino |
 |
Italian |
| 2015 | Prose | Anne Milano Appel | Blindly by Claudio Magris |
Susan Harris - Diana Thow - Paul Vangelisti |
 |
Italian |
